CHRISTMAS25 FOR 25% off orders!

Collection: Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookies

Happy Halloween y'all! Our Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookies are 13% off for Halloween! We now have these earrings in a Jumbo and Mini size, and have them available as keychains in the Normal size! Stay safe this Halloween and thank you for checking out this update on our shop!

10 random orders from this update will receive a free Candy Corn Corgi!

19 products
  • MINI SIZE Pillsbury Inspired Ghost Sugar Cookie Earrings
    MINI SIZE Pillsbury Inspired Ghost Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $17
  • MINI SIZE Mix and Match Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    MINI SIZE Mix and Match Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    $17
    Sale price
    $17
  • MINI SIZE Pillsbury Inspired Pumpkin Sugar Cookie Earrings
    MINI SIZE Pillsbury Inspired Pumpkin Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    $17
    Sale price
    $17
  • Pillsbury Inspired Pumpkin Sugar Cookie Earrings - Medium
    Pillsbury Inspired Pumpkin Sugar Cookie Earrings - Medium
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $23
  • Pillsbury Inspired Ghost Sugar Cookie Earrings - Medium
    Pillsbury Inspired Ghost Sugar Cookie Earrings - Medium
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $23
  • Mix and Match Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings - Medium
    Mix and Match Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings - Medium
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $23
  • JUMBO SIZE Mix and Match Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    JUMBO SIZE Mix and Match Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $25
  • JUMBO SIZE Pillsbury Inspired Ghost Sugar Cookie Earrings
    JUMBO SIZE Pillsbury Inspired Ghost Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $25
  • Pillsbury Inspired Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Pillsbury Inspired Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    $25
    Sale price
    $25
  • Reindeer Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Reindeer Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    $25
    Sale price
    $25
  • Snowman Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Snowman Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    $23
    Sale price
    $23
  • SET OF 3 - Holiday Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    SET OF 3 - Holiday Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $62
  • Pillsbury Inspired Valentine's Day Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Pillsbury Inspired Valentine's Day Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $20
  • JUMBO SIZE Pillsbury Inspired Pumpkin Sugar Cookie Earrings
    JUMBO SIZE Pillsbury Inspired Pumpkin Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    Sold out
    Sale price
    $25
  • Mini Snowman Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Mini Snowman Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    $20
    Sale price
    $20
  • Tiny Reindeer Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Tiny Reindeer Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    $20
    Sale price
    $20
  • Mini Pillsbury Inspired Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Mini Pillsbury Inspired Christmas Tree Sugar Cookie Earrings
    Regular price
    $20
    Sale price
    $20
  • Reindeer Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Ornament
    Reindeer Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Ornament
    Regular price
    $12
    Sale price
    $12
  • Christmas Tree Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Ornament
    Christmas Tree Pillsbury Inspired Sugar Cookie Ornament
    Regular price
    $12
    Sale price
    $12